Time is running out to order holiday gifts, but panic-buying random beauty products isn’t the answer. These last-minute beauty stocking stuffers under $25 prove that thoughtful gifting doesn’t require weeks of planning or a massive budget. From mini mascaras and cream eyeshadows to travel-sized luxuries that feel far more expensive than they are, these picks deliver quality, practicality, and that little spark of joy every stocking stuffer should bring. Whether you’re filling stockings for your daughter, best friend, or treating yourself to something small and special, these finds make last-minute shopping feel surprisingly intentional.
The Best Last-Minute Beauty Stocking Stuffers Under $25
1. One-Swipe Cream Eyeshadow
Merit Solo Shadow Cream Eyeshadow
A buildable cream eyeshadow that gives a sheer wash of color and blends effortlessly with zero creasing or fallout. The compact stick design makes application foolproof—swipe on with fingers, blend, and go. Perfect for anyone who wants elevated eye makeup without the fuss of brushes and palettes.
2. The Mascara Duo Everyone Wants
Benefit Cosmetics Mini What’s That Lash Mascara Duo Gift Set
Two mini bestselling mascaras in one adorable set—BADgal BANG! for volume and Roller Lash for super-curled lashes. This duo lets her choose her lash vibe depending on the day. The travel sizes are TSA-friendly and perfect for trying both formulas without committing to full sizes.
More Budget Beauty Ideas
If you’re filling multiple stockings and need even more affordable ideas, don’t miss my 6 Beauty Gifts Under $25 That Look Way More Expensive Than They Are. From NYX lip gloss vaults to e.l.f. beauty kits, that post is packed with budget finds that deliver luxury vibes without the luxury prices. These lists work perfectly together for creating thoughtful, varied stockings without overspending. See all the under-$25 beauty gifts here →
3. Real-Life Filter in a Bottle
Charlotte Tilbury Mini Hollywood Flawless Filter
This customizable, mini-size complexion booster blurs, smooths, and illuminates skin for a real-life filter effect. Wear it under foundation, mix it in, or use it alone for an instant glow. The mini size is perfect for purses, travel, or anyone wanting to try Charlotte Tilbury’s most iconic product.
4. Makeup Removal Made Easy
The Original MakeUp Eraser Strawberry Fields 14-Day Set
Fourteen patented, water-activated, cloud-soft wipes that gently remove all makeup and sunscreen from pores—no cleanser needed. They’re reusable, machine-washable, and eliminate the need for disposable wipes. Eco-friendly, effective, and adorable in strawberry pink.
5. The Eyeliner That Never Quits
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
This bestselling luxury eye pencil glides on ultra-creamy and delivers long-lasting eyeliner looks that won’t smudge, fade, or budge. Available in dozens of shades beyond basic black, it’s perfect for creating everything from classic lines to smoky eyes. The built-in sharpener keeps it precise.
Winter Beauty Essentials
Speaking of eye makeup, Jennifer just shared 6 Winter Beauty Essentials to Make Your Face the Focal Point This Holiday Season—featuring strategic makeup tips and products that help you look polished and party-ready during the busiest time of year.
Her approach to highlighting your best features while keeping everything else effortless pairs perfectly with these stocking stuffer finds. See Jennifer’s winter beauty essentials here →
6. The Blender Set Everyone Needs
Sephora Collection Pillow Dream Makeup Sponge Set
Four super-soft makeup sponges suitable for all textures, packaged in an adorable mini pouch. These blend foundation, concealer, and cream products flawlessly while the pouch keeps them clean and organized. It’s the practical stocking stuffer that actually gets used every single day.
7. Selena’s Lash and Brow Duo
Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez Lash & Brow Essentials Duo Makeup Gift Set
Travel-size Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara plus full-size Brow Harmony Shape & Fill Gel for sculpted, natural-looking brows. This set covers two essential steps in one cute package, making it perfect for teens, college students, or anyone building their makeup collection.
8. L’Occitane Luxury Minis
L’Occitane Hand and Body Care Nourishing Travel Favorites
Intense nourishment featuring a body cleanser and the iconic shea butter hand cream that’s rich, fast-absorbing, and smells incredible. The travel sizes are TSA-approved and perfect for winter trips. L’Occitane always feels luxurious, making this an elevated stocking stuffer.
✨ Beth’s Last-Minute Stocking Stuffer Strategy
Shop by category: One skincare item, one makeup item, one fragrance sample keeps stockings balanced and interesting.
Think travel-friendly: Mini sizes work for everyone—frequent travelers, gym-goers, or anyone who likes keeping products in multiple bags.
Consider the recipient’s skill level: Cream eyeshadows and tinted lip treatments work for beginners; eyeliner pencils and mascaras suit makeup lovers.
Don’t skip presentation: Even last-minute gifts look thoughtful with tissue paper, small gift bags, or festive ribbon.
Buy extras: When something costs under $15 and works well, grab multiples. Suddenly you have teacher gifts, coworker presents, and backup stockings solved.
9. The Fragrance Discovery Set
KAYALI Discovery Layering Mini Perfume Sampler Set
Eight of Mona Kattan’s favorite fragrances in travel-friendly sizes—from decadent gourmands to irresistible fruity florals. Wear them alone or layer them together to discover your own signature scent combination. This set makes fragrance exploration accessible and fun without committing to full bottles.
10. Mini Lip Treatment Collection
Tower 28 Beauty Mini Lil’ Softies LipSoftie Lip Treatment Set
Four mini tinted lip treatments including two new shades exclusive to this kit. These clean, vegan balms deliver sheer color and serious hydration without any sticky feeling. The minis are perfect for trying multiple shades and keeping one in every purse, pocket, and travel bag.
Still Need More Gift Ideas?
If you’re shopping beyond just stocking stuffers, my Early Holiday Beauty Deals Are Too Good to Miss post features incredible sales on full-size products, luxury sets, and beauty tools at prices that won’t last. These deals pair perfectly with stocking stuffers for creating complete beauty gifts that hit multiple price points.
Closing Thoughts
Last-Minute Beauty Stocking Stuffers
Last-minute doesn’t have to mean thoughtless. These beauty stocking stuffers under $25 prove that small gifts can feel special, luxurious, and perfectly chosen—even when you’re shopping days before the holidays. From mini mascaras that introduce someone to their new favorite formula to cream eyeshadows that simplify morning routines, each of these picks delivers real value and genuine usefulness. The best stocking stuffers aren’t fillers—they’re little discoveries that bring joy long after the wrapping paper is cleaned up.
LEAVE A COMMENT