Free Gift!

denim guide for women

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive Beth’s Denim Guide for Women as our gift to you.

Subscriptions

7 Eyeliner Tips for Aging Eyes: Products & Techniques for a Youthful Look

💬 Affiliate Support (Thank You!)

Style at a Certain Age uses affiliate links throughout our posts. When you shop through these links, you support the work my team and I do every single day — at no extra cost to you.

Thank you for being part of the SaaCA community. Your support truly means the world.

Hope everyone had a wonderful Thanksgiving and that you are continuing to enjoy plenty of yummy leftovers! Here’s a pic of my family and me from Thursday that I’m so very thankful for.

Family photo of Jennifer with her 3 teenage kids and husband

Now that we are in full-blown holiday mode and the parties and gatherings are in full swing, we need to accentuate our makeup looks, and the area I like to play up the most is the EYES. And since our eyes are the first things people notice and focus on when we are communicating with one another, enhancing them is key!  Today, I’m sharing 6 eyeliner tips for aging eyes.

Jennifer, a woman in her 40s with long hair shows her full face of makeup, smiling a tthe camera

And as we age, our skin loses elasticity, becomes more delicate, and overall our eye beds seem to appear much smaller. This can pose a slight challenge when it comes to applying eye makeup…especially EYELINER. Many of the techniques we used in our youth may no longer be suitable for aging eyes.

Jennifer holds a variety of eyeliner pencils

However, this does NOT mean you should give up on using eyeliner altogether! Quite the opposite. Note my with and without eyeliner photo below as an example of why you should give eyeliner a chance.

When used correctly, it can 100% benefit your overall eye bed and help you to achieve a youthful, more awake, and polished look.

Jennifer shows one eye with eye makeup and one eye without eye makeup

Shop the Post

​​

Here are some of the best eyeliner practices + products to consider…

7 Eyeliner Tips For Aging Eyes

Morphe Eye lid primer product

1. Create a Transfer Proof Base

I never start an eye makeup look without applying an eyelid primer to make shadow and eyeliner STAY PUT. I also love one that color corrects the eyelid at the same time, and this Morphe Priming cream eyeshadow one, $10, is a low cost dupe to my fave MAC Cosmetics paint pots, $28! Give it a try if you want to extend the wear of your eyeshadow and eyeliner and maximize color intensity.

I wear shade “Debut,” which is a soft pink and similar to the “Painterly” shade from MAC. I apply this with my finger to warm it up and spread it all over the eyelid down to the lash line in a sheer layer.

2. Choose a Soft Eyeliner Pencil Over Liquid

Using a soft eyeliner pencil will make it easier to apply eyeliner to delicate skin. A soft pencil will glide on smoothly without tugging or pulling. It will also not look as harsh as a liquid liner. Look for a waterproof or long-wearing formula to ensure that your eyeliner stays put all day.

several colors of eye pencil drawn on a forearm to see the colors against natural skin tone

My favorite formulas right now in different categories are:

Prestige

Drugstore

Shop the Post

​​
A woman in her 40s shows her finished eye look while holding three eyeliner pencil products

3. Choose a Lighter Shade of Eyeliner

As we age, our eyelashes tend to thin out, and dark black eyeliner can accentuate this. Instead, opt for a lighter shade of eyeliner, such as a deep brown and charcoal gray, OR more fun shades like plum or sapphire blue.

These shades will still define your eyes without overwhelming them. All of the above brands I mentioned offer a variety of these shades. The Urban Decay pencil collection wins for having the most shade offerings and finishes, however. If you can dream of a color, the UD pencils win!

4. Smudge Your Eyeliner

Don’t just draw on your eyeliner and be done. Go a step further and start smudging in your eyeliner after application. This will give it a softer, more natural look you’ll love. Get yourself a really good tiny eyeliner brush like my go-to Bobbi Brown Ulta Fine Liner brush, $43, that I’ve owned for years!! These brushes hold up and are wonderful investments. If you want a less expensive option, this Morphe M362 pointed liner brush, $7. 

Once you’ve drawn your line, immediately take the liner brush and go right on top of it, and do tiny sweeps back and forth to blend out the edges. This will create a subtle, smoky effect that will enhance your eyes. 

For extra credit, add a matching eyeshadow onto the liner brush, which will secure and soften the liner even more and even pull the liner out into a baby wing. I promise, this small step makes a big and lovely impact.

Jennifer demonstrating the tight-lining technique on her left eye

5. Use Eyeliner Sparingly

Less is more when it comes to eyeliner for aging eyes. Applying too much or too thick a liner can make your eyes look heavy and tired. Instead, apply a thin line of eyeliner along the lash line, focusing mostly on the outer corners of the eyes, and your line should get thinner as you head in toward the tear duct. A thin line that varies in thickness is a more pleasant look than a thick block line! 

But do tightline the UPPER lash line as well – this means to color in the upper underneath side of your lashline to get rid of the fleshy color and darken it as you can see my doing above.

Shop the Post

​​

6. Avoid Applying Dark Eyeliner On The Waterline

Now, if you want to shrink the size of your eye bed, you would also apply the dark eyeliner along the lower inner waterline. But most of us find that our eye beds are shrinking in size as we age, and want to see the opposite, and want to make our eyes appear bigger! 

So that would mean you’d want to apply a WHITE or NUDE shade of eyeliner just along the lower inner waterline instead of a dark shade.

Jennifer smiling at the camera showing two light-colored eye pencils for lining the water line
Jennifer applying white eyeliner to her water line

This will make the whites of your eyes appear more open and alert. My choice for the inner water liners are the Tarte Fake Awake Waterline Liner, $24, which claims to be safe for contact lens wearers. But you can also get a similar look for less from the Flower Beauty “moonstone” liner, $9, found on Amazon or the Revolution Beauty Streamline Waterline liners, $6 (wearing the bright white shade in 2nd pic above).

Jennifer showing one eye lined with white, and the other eye unlined

7. Use Eyeshadow Instead of Eyeliner On Lower Lash Line

Do you keep the lower lash line bare or not? The age-old question! My feelings toward the lower lash line is to definitely put some color there, but to use your eyeliner brush and a light or medium shadow of powder eyeshadow instead of traditional eyeliner.  If you swipe a little bit of shadow ¾ the way along the lower lashline, it creates a nice, subtle frame under the eyes. 

A woman in her 40s shows her finished eye look while holding three eyeliner pencil products

Shop the Post

​​

Closing Thoughts

Eyeliner Tips for Aging Eyes

In conclusion, the best eyeliner practices for aging eyes involve using soft pencils, lighter shades, and smudging techniques to create a natural and youthful look. With these tips, you can enhance your eyes and look your best at any age.
If you are interested in purchasing some new eyeliner for yourself or makeup gifts for a loved one, you can check out my past Sephora Sales Event post because a few of the ones I mentioned are now on sale! And try out this Halo Eye Makeup look tutorial to go with your eyeliner techniques!

About The Author

LEAVE A COMMENT

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Mary

    Thank you for the eyeliner tips. I will try these. My biggest challenge as I age is that the ends of my eyebrows have become coarse and are going in all directions. The middle and inner brows are smooth but the hair is longer and some gray is starting to show. I would love a plan to improve the looks of my eyebrows and know you are the person to help. Thank you.

  2. Susan Brackman

    I’ll certainly use these eyeliner tips. I always find interesting and helpful tips.
    Thank you,
    Susan Brackman

  3. Cindi Jones

    I enjoyed this tutorial very much. I will be 82 at Christmas, but using makeup has never stopped. Techniques change with age and I appreciate you sharing with older ladies. Just wanted you to know that you have an older audience that loves what you do. Thanks!🩷

  4. Cheryll Sampson

    Thank you for the eyeliner tips. My eyes are aging, and I did not wear eyeliner for awhile, but I love wearing it and went back to it a few months ago. Your tips are very useful,

  5. JoAnn

    I read a comment by an opthomologist who advised that you should never put any eye makeup on the part of your eyelid that has contact with your eye. If you think about it, there is no way to sterilize your eye makeup.

  6. Linda

    I am going to try some of these products and your reccomended techniques. I wear Lancome products, but my waterproof eyeliner melts onto the under eye area, making me look like I have dark circles.

  7. Belinda Taylor

    Love reading your post every Saturday & I continue to use products & tips you recommend!!!

  8. Karen

    JennySue Makeup-
    How do you keep your bangs so perfect? And the rest of your hair too! Also, can you recommend both hair products, skin care and makeup from the drug store?

    Thanks!

Navy Coat winter outfit

Free Gift!

denim guide
for women

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive Beth’s Denim Guide for Women as our gift to you.

Grit & Glam Weekly

GRIT & GLAM WEEKLY PICKS